Justice-Denied · Editorial cartoons
Cartoon 23 of 26
The Privacy Rug
Satire. Dialogue is imagined; the underlying rulings and records are linked below.
Read cartoon text
Masthead: JUSTICE-DENIED | SATIRE
Series: DOCKET CLEANING
Title: THE PRIVACY RUG
Panel 1: MARCH 2023
Marie presents a closed PRIVACY REQUEST folder at Judge Miller’s bench.
Marie: Please deal with the public filing.
Panel 2: REQUEST STILL PENDING
The request remains on the floor as the calendar turns from March to June; the judge holds a broom and rolled rug.
Panel 3: JUNE 2023
The judge sweeps the closed request beneath a MOOT rug beside a DISMISSED case file.
Judge Miller: That takes care of the request.
Panel 4: THE BUMP REMAINS
Marie points to a bump under the rug while a PUBLIC ACCESS lamp remains lit. No confidential contents are displayed.
Marie: The request is gone. The exposure isn’t.
Footer:
SATIRE • IMAGINED SCENES AND DIALOGUE
Doc. 421, pp. 32–33, 69–70; Doc. 429, p. 1.
Behind the cartoon
At the March 2023 hearing, plaintiffs’ counsel raised public use of designated-confidential information and sought permission to move. The judge said he would return to it. The hearing ended without that return; the June dismissal made pending requests moot. The continuing public-access effect follows the site’s September 22, 2026 review.
Underlying records
- Doc. 421, pp. 32–33, 69–70Doc. 421, pp. 32–33, 69–70; At the March 2023 hearing, plaintiffs’ counsel raised public use of designated-confidential information and sought permission to move. The judge said he would return to it. The hearing ended without that return; the June dismissal made pending requests moot. The continuing public-access effect follows the site’s September 22, 2026 review.
- Doc. 429, p. 1Doc. 429, p. 1; At the March 2023 hearing, plaintiffs’ counsel raised public use of designated-confidential information and sought permission to move. The judge said he would return to it. The hearing ended without that return; the June dismissal made pending requests moot. The continuing public-access effect follows the site’s September 22, 2026 review.
Docket Cleaning series. Cleaning equipment, scenes, and dialogue are imagined editorial satire. Court-page locators refer to original document pages. The public-access effect depicts the historical condition described in Justice-Denied’s September 22, 2026 review.
More record detail
Stevenson v. Stevenson, Otter Tail County case 56-CV-20-2928. At the March 2023 hearing, plaintiffs’ counsel raised public use of designated-confidential information and sought permission to move. The judge said he would return to it. The hearing ended without that return; the June dismissal made pending requests moot. The continuing public-access effect follows the site’s September 22, 2026 review. Sources: Doc. 421, pp. 32–33, 69–70; Doc. 429, p. 1.
